# Data Centers and Our Communities: What We Know, What Remains Uncertain, and How Residents Can Decide

## A national evidence review with a Pennsylvania and Lehigh Valley focus

**Research cutoff: Wednesday, September 23, 2026.** This review includes events reported through that date. Where it matters, the report gives the date an event happened separately from the date it was reported. The South Whitehall Planning Commission's special meeting on Project Atlas was scheduled for 6:00 p.m. that evening at Parkland High School. As of this cutoff, no outcome of that meeting has been reported, and this report does not assume one.

The most important finding for Lehigh Valley residents is this. The costs and benefits of a data center depend on the specific project, its enforceable terms, and its utility contract, not on "data centers" in general. Right now, the largest local proposal, Project Atlas, has not given enough verified information to support a confident judgment either way. The township's own zoning officer recommended denial on September 3, 2026, citing missing and incomplete information. The developer's claims about jobs, taxes, and water are still unverified claims from an interested party.

---

## TL;DR

- **Project Atlas is unresolved and under-documented.** Edged US (through CDE Acquisitions LLC) proposes three data center buildings of about 492,285 sq ft each on about 410 acres across from Parkland High School. Trade press reports the campus at 725 MW. South Whitehall's zoning officer issued a 62-page review on September 3, 2026 recommending denial for non-compliance. The township consultant called the unchanged $9 billion budget and 725 MW figure "not credible" at the reduced scale. The Board of Commissioners, not the Planning Commission, holds final land-use authority. The current deadline to act is October 31, 2026.
- **Electricity costs are real, but they are regional and hard to pin on any one project.** PJM capacity prices rose from $28.92/MW-day (2024/25) to the capped $329.17, $333.44, and $325/MW-day for 2026/27 through 2028/29. PJM's independent market monitor, Monitoring Analytics, found that forecast data center load above existing load accounted for $21.3 billion, or 45%, of $47.2 billion in capacity costs across three auctions; a July 2026 update put the four-auction total at $29.4 billion of $63.6 billion (46%). Pennsylvania's new PUC model tariff (Final Order May 12, 2026) and PPL's approved large-load rate class (June 4, 2026) protect residents from some direct costs, not all. Wholesale capacity price changes are not the same as household bill changes.
- **Residents have real but bounded leverage.** Pennsylvania law requires municipalities to allow data centers somewhere and to approve plans that comply with the ordinance. Denials must rest on legally sound grounds. Upper Macungie's zoning board unanimously denied Air Products' 2.6 million sq ft proposal in May 2026, and the company did not appeal by the August 5 deadline. Governor Shapiro's Executive Order 2026-05 (August 18, 2026) now ties state permit review to local approval. The most useful thing residents can do is demand specific documents, measurements, and enforceable conditions.

---

Evidence labels used throughout: **[Fact]** documented fact; **[Claim]** attributed claim; **[Estimate]** estimate or projection; **[Inference]** research inference; **[Unknown]** unknown or disputed. Claim IDs (C01 and so on) refer to the register in Section D. Sections: A. Resident brief; B. Full report; C. Project table; D. Evidence register; E. Claims you will hear; F. Worksheet and questions; G. Website section; H. Content package; I. Maintenance; J. Limitations.

---

## A. Two-page resident brief

**What is proposed near us?** The biggest active proposal is Project Atlas in South Whitehall Township, Lehigh County. It covers about 410 acres at 2493 N. Cedar Crest Blvd, across from Parkland High School, on land owned by the Jeras Corporation (C10). The current plan has three data center buildings of about 492,285 sq ft each, a 40,680 sq ft accessory building, an electrical substation, a cell tower, 267 parking spaces, and three stormwater ponds (C11). The first version, reviewed by the Lehigh Valley Planning Commission (LVPC) in late 2025, had six buildings and 5.1 million sq ft (C12). Trade press reports the power figure as 725 MW (C13). No public document reviewed here says what that number measures.

**Where does it stand?** Township engineer Anthony Tallarida told the Planning Commission on Thursday, July 9, 2026 that staff could not recommend preliminary plan approval. He cited deficiencies in site design, roadway layout, and stormwater (C14). Zoning Officer Kent Baird's 62-page review, dated September 3, 2026, recommends denial on the basis of non-compliance (C15). The Planning Commission met in special session on Wednesday, September 23, 2026 at Parkland High School. **No outcome had been reported as of this report's cutoff.** The Planning Commission only recommends. The Board of Commissioners decides. The current deadline to act is Saturday, October 31, 2026, unless the applicant agrees to another extension (C16).

**What does the developer promise?** Edged says the project will bring more than $8.9 billion in investment (as reported by WFMZ, alongside a claimed "$99.5 million projected annual economic impact"), 250 to 280 permanent jobs, and more than $16 million a year in taxes, including $11.5 million for the Parkland School District (C17). It also promises "zero water" for daily cooling from a closed-loop system and noise under 54 dB at property lines, and says it will pay for its own power infrastructure (C18, C19). **These are interested-party claims.** None had been independently verified in the public record reviewed. A township consultant said the $9 billion budget and 725 MW, unchanged after the project was cut in half, are "not credible" at the stated scale (C20).

**What do we know about electricity costs?** Regional capacity prices on the PJM grid rose about elevenfold from 2024/25 to 2026/27. They have stayed at a price cap since then (C05, C06). PJM's market monitor ties billions of dollars of those costs to forecasts of data centers that are not built yet (C07). Pennsylvania's regulators adopted a model tariff in May 2026 that asks utilities to charge large loads for upgrades that "would not have been needed 'but for'" them (C08). PPL's June 2026 rate settlement created a large-load class with commitments of at least 10 years (C09). These protections cover direct hookup costs better than they cover region-wide supply costs.

**What about water?** "Closed loop" usually means little ongoing cooling water on site. It does not mean zero total water. Water is still used for initial fill, sanitation, and power generation off site. The developer's "2.8 billion gallons saved" compares Atlas to a hypothetical evaporative design. It is not a measurement of Atlas's own use (C21).

**What has happened nearby?** Upper Macungie's zoning board unanimously denied Air Products' 2.6 million sq ft data center proposal on the former headquarters site in May 2026. Air Products let the August 5, 2026 appeal deadline pass (C22). In Upper Mount Bethel, a developer filed a validity challenge on July 23, 2026 against a proposed 2 GW campus, and talks on a memorandum of understanding (MOU) continue (C23). Allen Township approved converting a 1 million sq ft warehouse into a data center (C24).

**What can you do?**
1. Go to the Board of Commissioners meetings and focus comments on standards the ordinance actually contains.
2. File Right-to-Know requests for the engineer's and zoning officer's review letters, the PPL will-serve letter, and the noise study.
3. Ask that any promise you rely on, such as noise limits, generator testing hours, water use, or decommissioning, be written into enforceable conditions or a recorded agreement that binds future owners.

**Bottom line:** There is enough evidence to say that very large data centers impose real regional electricity and local land-use pressures. There is also enough evidence to say they can produce significant tax revenue. There is not enough evidence to say whether Project Atlas's specific promises will hold.

---

## B. Full research report

### 1. Audit of the PRISM website

**Access limitation (disclosed):** The homepage https://safety.prismaiconsultants.com/ returned "Site disallows automated access" when fetched on September 23, 2026. Searches found no indexed Data Center Desk, Project Atlas page, source list, or verification policy on that subdomain. **This review did not read any page on the site.** The table below is not a record of claims found. It is a checklist of claims that commonly appear on local data center trackers, with the verified status of each. PRISM staff should compare each row with the live pages.

> PRISM NOTE, added on filing 2026-09-23: this premise was tested and is incorrect. The site returns HTTP 200 to plain curl, to a blank user agent, and to GPTBot, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot, and robots.txt allows all crawlers except /admin/. The fetch failure was on the research tool's side. The audit table below is still useful as a checklist, and several rows had already been fixed before this report arrived.

| Page (to check) | Claim type to check | Finding (as of Sept 23, 2026) | Recommended replacement | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Data Center Desk | Cetronia Road / Air Products listed as "pending" | Ended; ZHB denied in May 2026; no appeal after Aug 5 deadline | "Denied by Upper Macungie ZHB (May 27, 2026 hearing); no appeal filed; abandonment confirmed (reported Aug 2026)." | C22 |
| Project Atlas | "5.1 million sq ft, six buildings" | Outdated | "Current plan: three buildings of about 492,285 sq ft each on about 410 acres" | C11, C12 |
| Project Atlas | "725 MW" stated as consumption | Meaning unclear | "Reported capacity of 725 MW (DCD, July 8, 2026); not actual consumption" | C13 |
| Project Atlas | "Zero water" as fact | Developer claim only | "Developer claims no municipal water for daily cooling; other uses not addressed" | C18, C21 |
| Project Atlas | "Planning commission approved/rejected" | No outcome reported | "Special PC meeting held Sept 23, 2026; outcome not yet reported. Board decides by Oct 31, 2026" | C16 |
| Source list | Developer or advocacy sites classified as neutral | Wrong classification | Label projectatlaspa.com and opposeatlasdc.com "interested party" | Section 3 standards |
| Source list | News classified as "official records" | Wrong classification | Label as "secondary reporting" | Section 3 standards |
| Any page | Bill increases equated with capacity price increases | Misleading | "Capacity is one part of supply cost; bill effects vary" | C05 to C07 |
| Verification policy | Not reviewable | Unknown | Publish date-stamped "last verified" fields | Section I |

**Conflict-of-interest note [Fact]:** PRISM AI Consultants is an AI implementation business (C30). Its public education on data centers should disclose that the firm's commercial interest is in AI adoption. That interest is not evidence of bias. It is a relevant fact readers should have.

### 2. Fundamentals

**What data centers do.** Data centers are buildings full of servers, storage, and network equipment. They run websites, banking, streaming, cloud software, telehealth, and AI. LVPC planner Mary Grace Collins described them as "the physical space that actually makes all of those things happen" (C25).

**Types:** Enterprise (one organization's own use); colocation (space and power leased to many tenants); hyperscale (very large campuses, often 100 MW or more); cloud (hyperscale capacity sold as a service); cryptocurrency mining (power-dense, often interruptible, few employees); AI-focused (dense GPU clusters, often liquid cooled).

**Training versus inference.** Training builds a model. It is concentrated, power hungry, and can sometimes be located far from users. Inference runs the model for users and grows with use.

**When the tenant is secret.** Parkland School District reports that the Atlas tenant is under a nondisclosure agreement. With an undisclosed tenant, residents cannot know the workload mix, the utilization, or whether the load will be flexible. A 725 MW figure is consistent with AI-scale density. About 490 W per sq ft across roughly 1.48 million sq ft of data hall space is an [Inference] from arithmetic. It does not prove any specific use.

**Why location matters.** Developers look for high-voltage transmission and substation capacity, fiber, large parcels with suitable zoning, nearby customers, taxes, water, and permitting speed. LVPC's Jill Seitz said the Lehigh Valley is attractive "thanks to strong energy and transmission infrastructure, nearby major population centers and space available for development" (C25).

**Stages are not the same thing.** In order: announcement, then application, then approval, then utility request, then signed utility agreement, then construction, then operation. PPL's "advanced" pipeline was 28.3 GW by 2034 as of May 2026 (C26). That figure is a request-stage number. It is not demand that will certainly arrive.

**Units in plain language:**
- **MW** is a rate of power at a moment. **MWh** is energy over time. One MW running for an hour is one MWh.
- **Peak demand** is the highest draw. **Average consumption** is the typical draw. **Capacity** is the maximum allowed. **Utilization** is the share actually used.
- A 725 MW campus running at a 50% average would use about 3.2 TWh a year (725 MW x 8,760 hours x 0.5). At 100% it would use 6.35 TWh. This is arithmetic, not a forecast.
- **PUE** is total facility energy divided by IT energy. **WUE** is liters of site water per kWh of IT energy.

### 3. National picture

**Measured history [Fact, national estimate].** Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL), in a December 2024 report funded by DOE, estimates that U.S. data centers used 58 TWh in 2014, about 76 TWh (1.9%) in 2018, and 176 TWh in 2023, which was 4.4% of U.S. electricity (C01). These are modeled estimates built from equipment shipment data, not metered totals.

**Projections [Estimate].** LBNL projects 325 to 580 TWh by 2028, equal to 6.7% to 12.0% of U.S. electricity. At an assumed 50% average utilization, that would mean 74 to 132 GW of demand (C02). The range is wide because AI server shipments, efficiency gains, and utilization are all uncertain.

| Source | Published | Baseline | Scenario | Geography | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LBNL / DOE | Dec 2024 | 176 TWh (2023) | 325 to 580 TWh by 2028 | U.S. | Shipment-based; pre-dates 2025 to 2026 capex surge and cancellations |
| PJM load forecast (via auctions) | Jan 2026; auctions Dec 2025, Jul 2026 | About 127 GW peak for 2027/28 | 152 GW reliability requirement | 13 states + DC | Monitor calls data center load uncertainty "unprecedented" (C07) |
| PPL "advanced" pipeline | May 2026 | 25.2 GW (Feb 2026) | 28.3 GW by 2034 | PPL territory | Requests, not commitments; may double count |

**Where forecasts agree and differ.** All sources agree demand is growing and concentrated in a few regions. They differ on how much, how fast, and how much requested load will be built. Pennsylvania's 2026/27 budget law gives the PUC authority to "review and validate load forecasts" and to "prevent duplicative counting of projects" (C27). At his August 18, 2026 press conference, Gov. Shapiro said, as an attributed claim reported by NBC News and NBC10, that "there are only about five projects that have even received permits... The problem is there's 100 projects or so that are wreaking havoc on our communities that are never going to be built" (C28).

**Grid constraints.** PJM cleared 6,625 MW below its reliability target for 2027/28 and about 6,800 MW below for 2028/29. Its reserve margin for 2028/29 was 14.7%, compared with a 20% target (C06). In a July 31, 2026 FERC filing, PJM proposed a one-time reliability backstop auction running from September 30 to October 21, 2026 to fill a 6.8 GW shortfall (Utility Dive, August 3, 2026).

### 4. Community impacts

#### 4.1 Electricity, bills, and reliability

**How costs arise.** Direct costs (substations, lines, interconnection) can be assigned to the customer by tariff. System-wide costs (generation capacity, energy prices) are spread across the region. A developer paying for its own substation does not stop it from adding to regional demand, which raises capacity prices for everyone in PJM.

**Strongest evidence:**
- **[Fact]** PJM capacity prices: $28.92/MW-day (2024/25); $269.92 (2025/26, most zones); $329.17 (2026/27); $333.44 (2027/28, at cap); $325 (2028/29, at cap, results posted July 14, 2026) (C05, C06).
- **[Estimate]** PJM estimated that without the cap, 2027/28 would have cleared near $530/MW-day. A PJM simulation reported secondhand put 2028/29 at $554.72 (C06).
- **[Attributed claim / independent monitor]** Monitoring Analytics said $6.2 billion of 2027/28 costs relate to data centers not yet built, and that forecast data center load above existing load accounted for $21.3 billion, or 45%, of $47.2 billion across the last three auctions (C07). A July 2026 update from the monitor's Joseph Bowring put the four-auction total at $29.4 billion of $63.6 billion (46%). Its attribution depends on its own counterfactual method.

**Counterevidence and limits.** PJM notes that capacity "accounts for a fraction of wholesale electricity costs." Retirements, slow interconnection of new generation, and market rules also drive prices. The price cap and floor, extended through 2029/30, limit swings in both directions.

**Pennsylvania protections [Fact]:**
- **PUC model tariff.** Final Order entered May 12, 2026, Docket M-2025-3054271. It applies to loads above 50 MW individually or 100 MW in aggregate, gives guidance on interconnection costs, studies, minimum contract terms, exit fees, and collateral, and applies the "but for" standard to upgrades (C08). It is **nonbinding** guidance. The Energy Association of Pennsylvania filed for reconsideration.
- **PPL rate settlement.** Approved June 4, 2026: a $275 million distribution increase and a new large-load class with "long-term service commitments, minimum demand guarantees, financial protections intended to reduce cost shifting" (C09).
- **What remains open [Unknown].** Neither measure prevents regional capacity price effects. Residents should ask whether Atlas will take service under PPL's large-load class, and what collateral and exit fees apply.

**Attributed claim to treat carefully.** Elizabeth Marx, executive director of the Pennsylvania Utility Law Project, told WHYY: "We are already paying in the neighborhood of a billion dollars more this year in generation costs... directly attributed to the load growth from data centers" (secondary reporting, C29). This is plausible given the monitor's figures, but it was not verified for this report.

**Reliability.** Large loads can stress voltage and frequency. A PUC staffer wrote, per secondary reporting, "There is no debate that voltage and frequency excursions on the transmission network create reliability concerns." Whether Atlas would commit to any load flexibility is [Unknown]. **Rule:** Do not convert a capacity price change directly into a household bill change.

#### 4.2 Water

Withdrawal is water taken; consumption is water not returned, usually because it evaporates. Evaporative towers consume the most on site; closed-loop dry coolers use little ongoing water but more electricity; hybrid systems switch by season. Power plants that supply the electricity also use water.

- **[Claim]** Edged says closed-loop cooling "would require no water from South Whitehall Township's municipal system." Edged CIO John Callahan said it could save more than 2.8 billion gallons a year, equal to "the usage of 50,000 homes"; the Project Atlas FAQ gives "approximately 2.85 billion gallons" (C18, C21).
- **[Fact]** Lehigh Valley Public Media, citing Lehigh County Authority's website, reports that LCA's Central Lehigh Division "supplies about 4.1 billion gallons of water each year to more than 18,000 residential and commercial customers." The claimed "savings" equal about two thirds of that supply. The comparison is against a hypothetical design, not a measured baseline.
- **[Fact]** The Cetronia Road submission reused 2022 warehouse water documents showing 95,000 gallons per day (C22).
- **[Fact]** A 2026 state law requires data centers of 10 MW or more to report water and electricity use every year, with fines of $10,000 per day for failing to report (C27). This creates measured data after operation, not before approval.

#### 4.3 Noise, air quality, and health

Sources include cooling fans and chillers (continuous, sometimes tonal and low-frequency), transformers, construction, and backup generator testing.

- **[Claim]** Edged says noise will be "less than 54 dB at property lines."
- **[Fact]** LVPC recommended that municipalities cap property-line noise at 55 dB and suggested Upper Macungie extend a 65 dB limit to data centers (secondary reporting).
- **[Fact]** Parkland SD reports that the second plan kept 356 backup generators, upgraded at its request from Tier 2 to Tier 4, the strictest EPA tier for nonroad engines.
- **[Fact]** The township manager disputed the applicant's claim that generators are exempt from noise rules, saying routine testing counts as normal operations.
- **[Fact]** Advisory boards asked for full acoustic modeling and continuous noise monitoring for at least the first year (secondary reporting).

General research on noise and diesel exhaust shows plausible exposure pathways. It does **not** prove that this unbuilt project will harm anyone. What matters is measured decibels, including low-frequency weighting, at specific receptors at night, and whether limits and testing hours are enforceable in writing. None of these had been finalized as of the cutoff.

#### 4.4 Jobs, taxes, and economic development

**[Claim]** Atlas's claimed figures: about 250 permanent jobs at $65,000 to $75,000 average wages (project website); 280 jobs (July 9 meeting); 3,390 construction-period jobs; $2.9 billion in construction activity; $99.5 million a year in economic impact; $16.2 million to $16.5 million a year in taxes (C17). The two job figures conflict. Construction "jobs" in impact studies are often temporary job-years.

**Net fiscal benefit is unknown.** Pennsylvania real estate taxes depend on the assessed value of land and buildings; equipment is generally not taxed as real property. Assessment appeals can shrink revenue. Service costs, such as emergency response for battery fires, roads, and inspections, need to be subtracted. Parkland SD lists "unresolved tax/assessment estimates" among its concerns. No independent fiscal analysis was found. There is also no evidence reviewed here that hosting a data center creates a local AI innovation economy; the permanent staff is small relative to the investment.

#### 4.5 Land, schools, property, and quality of life

**[Fact]** LVPC projected 1,154 weekday trips for Atlas. Homes would be more than 1,000 ft from the data center buildings and the high school about 1,700 ft (developer figures). Advisory boards noted about 72 acres of woodland cleared versus about 12 reforested. Karst geology is under review. The substation would sit across from the high school.

**[Claim]** The developer offers a 160-acre Jordan Creek Greenway dedication and argues by-right warehouses would generate more truck traffic. That has some support: Air Products' Cetronia Road study projected 930 cars and 19 trucks a day for a data center versus 1,534 cars and 286 trucks for warehouses (C22). "Less traffic than a warehouse" is not "no impact."

**Property values [Unknown].** No peer-reviewed Lehigh Valley study was found; national studies are mixed and depend on distance and visibility. **[Inference]** Benefits such as taxes are spread across the township and district, while noise, views, and construction fall on nearby households. Renters get no tax relief but share regional electricity costs.

#### 4.6 Climate, lifecycle, and future risk

Operational emissions depend on the grid mix, and hourly matching matters more than annual renewable certificates. EO 2026-05's GRID requirements include clean firm energy commitments ramping from 10% to 32% by January 1, 2035, for projects that sign on (C28). Servers turn over every few years, creating waste and embodied emissions. **[Inference]** Vacancy and demand shortfalls are real risks, which is why a decommissioning bond and restoration obligations should be recorded against the land.

### 5. Pennsylvania and Lehigh Valley assessment

**State framework as of the cutoff [Fact]:**
- **Budget law (signed Sunday, July 12, 2026; HB 1924 language).** Data centers of 10 MW or more must report power and water use annually. The PUC gains oversight of load forecasts (C27).
- **Executive Order 2026-05 (signed Tuesday, August 18, 2026)** (C28). DEP reviews data center permit applications on a rolling basis only if the developer signs a Consent Order and Agreement committing to GRID requirements; others wait until all local approvals are obtained. Data centers are removed from Fast Track, agencies may not use NDAs, and DEP must publish a public map. The Governor's office said 58 projects had engaged with DEP, 15 had applied for at least one permit, and 5 had all first-phase permits. Legal challenges are possible; the order includes a severability clause.

#### Project Atlas (South Whitehall Township, Lehigh County)

- **Parties:** Applicant CDE Acquisitions LLC (some reports say "CDC"; check the township file); developer Edged US, with reported Scannell Properties involvement; landowner Jeras Corporation; tenant undisclosed.
- **Stage:** Preliminary land development plan, third revision, submitted July 9, 2026 and deemed administratively complete July 13. **Last verified: September 23, 2026.**
- **Size:** about 410 acres (applicant says 406); three data center buildings of about 492,285 sq ft each; accessory buildings; substation.
- **Power:** 725 MW reported (DCD, July 8, 2026); what it represents is not stated. A new PPL substation is described. No public PPL interconnection figure was found.
- **Cooling and water:** closed loop claimed; no public water balance.
- **Reviews:** Engineer could not recommend preliminary approval (July 9). Zoning officer recommends denial (September 3). LVPC found "the potential to align with FutureLV" if impacts are minimized and utility adequacy is shown. Parkland SD calls the plan "unacceptable" in current form. 4ward Planning (township consultant) called cost and power figures "not credible."
- **Zoning context:** Data centers are permitted in the PIRT overlay. The township manager has said any denial must rest on grounds that will survive appeal.
- **Next steps:** Planning Commission recommendation (September 23 outcome not yet reported); Board of Commissioners action by October 31, 2026; any appeal to the Court of Common Pleas. Separately: PPL service, DEP permits (now linked to local approval), and generator air permits.
- **Major unanswered questions:** what 725 MW represents; final generator count and testing schedule; low-frequency noise modeling; water balance; tenant; PPL service terms; decommissioning security; net fiscal analysis.

#### Other Lehigh Valley projects

- **Cetronia Road Data Center (Upper Macungie Township, Lehigh County).** Air Products proposed 2.6 million sq ft in three buildings on 194 acres at 7300 Cetronia Road. LVPC could not determine consistency with the regional plan. The ZHB unanimously denied the "similar use" appeal at the Wednesday, May 27, 2026 hearing. No appeal was filed by August 5, 2026; Air Products confirmed that in a statement reported August 11 to 12, 2026. **Status: ended.** Do not confuse with Lower Macungie.
- **2500 Liberty Drive (Allen Township, Northampton County).** Supervisors approved final land development plans to convert a 1 million sq ft warehouse into a data center (reported spring 2026). Power, tenant, and cooling were not found. **Status: approved land development; construction unverified.**
- **Slate Belt Holdings campus (Upper Mount Bethel Township, Northampton County).** Up to 2 GW proposed. Validity challenge filed July 23, 2026. A draft MOU would have included $50 million in nonprofit donations at full buildout; the solicitor said it is "not a binding contract." On Monday, August 24, 2026, supervisors voted 3-2 against abandoning MOU talks. A workshop is scheduled for Monday, September 28, 2026. **Status: contested.**
- **J.G. Petrucci / Peron Development (Lower Mount Bethel Township, Northampton County).** Hyperscale concept on farmland off Martins Creek Belvidere Hwy. As of May 2026, no formal proposal had been received. **Status: pre-application.** Do not confuse with Upper Mount Bethel.
- **Ordinances.** LVPC reported reviewing 11 data center zoning amendments by spring 2026, including in Upper Mount Bethel, Palmer, South Whitehall, Upper Macungie, Upper Saucon, North Whitehall, Lower Saucon, Lowhill, Bushkill, Washington (Northampton), Plainfield, Moore, Upper Nazareth, Lower Nazareth, Allentown, and Chapman.

### 6. Comparable communities

**Selection criteria.** Pennsylvania cases share the Municipalities Planning Code (MPC), PJM, and PUC context, and at least one case was needed for each outcome type. **Limitation:** this review did not obtain primary outcome data for long-operating facilities in Loudoun County, Prince William County, Georgia, Ohio, Texas, or Arizona. Comparisons of promises with outcomes are the weakest part of this report.

| Case | Promised | What happened | Protections that worked or failed | Comparability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Upper Macungie (Air Products) | Low traffic; same water as warehouse | ZHB denied "similar use"; no appeal (2026) | Similar-use standard; incomplete record | High |
| Jessup, Lackawanna Co. | About 1.1M sq ft, six 130 ft buildings | ZHB denied (vote Dec 23; written Jan 2): substation not an accessory or "public utility facility" | Zoning definitions | Moderate |
| Ransom Twp., Lackawanna Co. | Data center district via curative amendment | Dismissed 2-1; developer appealed citing exclusionary zoning | Tests limits of local denial | Moderate |
| Clifton Twp., Lackawanna Co. | Campus | ZHB denied validity challenge; appeal; settlement considered | Litigation pressure toward settlement | Moderate |
| Montour County (Talen) | Rezoning for large load | All three commissioners voted against | County rezoning authority | Moderate |
| Allen Twp. | Warehouse conversion | Approved | Reuse limits land impacts | High |
| Upper Mount Bethel | 2 GW; $50M donations | Validity challenge and MOU talks | Unresolved; nonbinding MOU | High |

**Lesson [Inference].** In Pennsylvania, local denials hold up best when they rest on ordinance text: definitions, similar-use tests, and incomplete applications. Developers often answer with validity challenges claiming exclusionary zoning.

### 7. Who decides what

General legal background from the MPC and Right-to-Know Law; statute text was not re-fetched. Consult a solicitor for specific cases.

- **Planning Commission:** advisory recommendations.
- **Board of Commissioners / Supervisors:** approves or denies land development plans; must approve plans that meet the ordinance; must give written reasons for denial; acts within 90 days unless extended, or the plan may be deemed approved; holds quasi-judicial conditional use hearings with party status and cross-examination, which is why the South Whitehall Civic Alliance asked for a formal hearing.
- **Zoning Hearing Board:** variances, special exceptions, interpretations, validity challenges.
- **Appeals:** to the Court of Common Pleas, generally within 30 days.
- **PUC and PPL:** electric service terms; public comment in rate cases.
- **DEP:** stormwater (Chapter 102), air, and water permits, now linked to local approval.
- **Right-to-Know Law:** written request to the open records officer; 5 business days to respond, possible 30-day extension; appeals to the Office of Open Records.

**What survives a sale.** Recorded conditions, recorded development agreements, and covenants generally run with the land. Press statements and website promises do not.

**Options:** (1) Approve as proposed: required if the plan fully complies; weakest protection. (2) Approve with enforceable conditions tied to ordinance standards: most realistic leverage. (3) Redesign, reduce, or relocate: through negotiation or ordinance, as with Atlas's cut from six buildings to three. (4) Delay: only with the applicant's agreement or for incomplete applications. (5) Deny: must cite specific non-compliance; the September 3 review provides a record; appeal risk is real.

**Personal AI use.** One person using less AI will not change whether Atlas is built. Siting follows aggregate demand and investor expectations, and local permitting turns on the ordinance, not consumer behavior. **AI safety versus infrastructure.** Approving a building says nothing about whether unsafe AI activity will happen there.

### 8. Resident decision framework

**Reasonably supported benefits:** large real estate tax base if assessments hold; less traffic than a warehouse; some skilled permanent jobs; greenway dedication if recorded.

**Reasonably supported risks:** regional capacity cost pressure; continuous and low-frequency noise; generator testing emissions; loss of 400 acres of open farmland; construction disruption; a substation near the school.

**Material unknowns:** what 725 MW means; tenant; water balance; noise modeling; net fiscal impact; PPL terms; decommissioning.

**Protections that could change the assessment:** recorded noise limits with continuous monitoring and penalties; generator testing limits; a water-use cap with reporting; a decommissioning bond; enrollment in PPL's large-load class with disclosed collateral; an independent fiscal study; a community benefits agreement binding successors.

**Evidence that would strengthen approval:** independent acoustic study showing night compliance; PPL letter confirming no cost shift; assessor-validated tax estimate; water balance showing minimal use. **Evidence that would strengthen opposition:** modeled exceedances; evaporative backup; large uncovered cost share; unresolved karst risk; refusal to record conditions.

**Values are not scores.** How much weight to give open space versus tax revenue is a value judgment. This framework does not assign a score.

---

## C. Lehigh Valley project comparison table

| Project | Municipality (County) | Developer / applicant | Stage (last verified Sept 23, 2026) | Land / building | Power | Water / cooling | Claims | Next event |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Project Atlas | South Whitehall (Lehigh) | Edged US / CDE Acquisitions LLC; Jeras Corp. | Preliminary plan, 3rd revision; zoning officer recommends denial | about 410 ac; 3 x about 492,285 sq ft | 725 MW reported | Closed loop claimed | $9B; 250 to 280 jobs; $16.2M to $16.5M/yr | Sept 23 PC outcome unreported; BOC deadline Oct 31 |
| Cetronia Road | Upper Macungie (Lehigh) | Air Products | Denied; no appeal; ended | 194 ac; 2.6M sq ft | Not disclosed | 95,000 gpd (reused) | Low traffic | Site use undecided |
| 2500 Liberty Dr | Allen (Northampton) | Not verified | Final land development approved | 1M sq ft warehouse | Not found | Not found | Not found | Verify permits |
| Slate Belt Holdings | Upper Mount Bethel (Northampton) | Slate Belt Holdings | Validity challenge; MOU talks | Not verified | Up to 2 GW (claimed) | In MOU scope | $50M donations | Workshop Sept 28 |
| Petrucci / Peron | Lower Mount Bethel (Northampton) | J.G. Petrucci Co., Peron | Pre-application (May 2026) | Farmland | Not disclosed | Not disclosed | None found | Watch for filing |

---

## D. Claim-and-evidence register

All claims last verified September 23, 2026.

| ID | Claim | Category | Source and location | Date / geography | Confidence and reason | Caveat | Update trigger |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C01 | US data centers used 176 TWh (4.4%) in 2023 | Fact (modeled) | LBNL-2001637, Exec. Summary | Dec 2024; US | High; national lab | Model estimate | New LBNL/EIA data |
| C02 | 325 to 580 TWh by 2028 (6.7% to 12%) | Estimate | LBNL Fig. ES-1 | Dec 2024; US | Medium; wide range | Pre-2025 inputs | Updated report |
| C05 | PJM capacity $28.92 (24/25) to $329.17 (26/27) | Fact | PJM results; IEEFA | PJM | High | One bill component | Next BRA |
| C06 | 2027/28 $333.44 cap, 6,625 MW short; 2028/29 $325 cap, 14.7% reserve | Fact | PJM releases Dec 17, 2025, Jul 14, 2026 | PJM | High | Uncapped figures are estimates | Backstop auction; Dec 2026 BRA |
| C07 | Monitor: $6.2B tied to unbuilt data centers; $21.3B of $47.2B | Attributed claim | Monitoring Analytics via Utility Dive | Early 2026; PJM | Medium-high | Counterfactual method | New monitor reports |
| C08 | PUC model tariff: >50 MW / 100 MW; "but for"; nonbinding | Fact | PUC Final Order, M-2025-3054271 | May 12, 2026; PA | High | Reconsideration filed | Reconsideration ruling |
| C09 | PPL large-load class, 10+ yr; $275M settlement | Fact | PUC release Jun 4, 2026 | PA / PPL | High | Review tariff text | PPL filings |
| C10 | Atlas: 410 ac, Jeras Corp., 2493 N. Cedar Crest | Fact (secondary) | WFMZ Sept 22, 2026 | South Whitehall | High | Applicant says 406 ac | Revised plan |
| C11 | 3 x about 492,285 sq ft + accessory + substation | Fact (secondary) | WFMZ Sept 22, 2026 | South Whitehall | High | Totals vary | Revised plan |
| C12 | Original: 6 buildings, 5.1M sq ft | Fact (secondary) | LVPM / WFMZ late 2025 | South Whitehall | High | Superseded | None |
| C13 | 725 MW | Attributed claim | DCD, Jul 8, 2026 | South Whitehall | Medium; meaning unstated | Not consumption | PPL or applicant document |
| C14 | Engineer could not recommend approval | Fact (secondary) | LV Press, Jul 16, 2026 | South Whitehall | High | 2nd submission | New letter |
| C15 | Sept 3 zoning review recommends denial | Fact (secondary) | WFMZ Sept 22 (snippet) | South Whitehall | Medium-high | Obtain letter | RTK release |
| C16 | BOC decides; deadline Oct 31, 2026 | Fact (secondary) | Citizen Portal Sept 2; WFMZ | South Whitehall | High | Extensions possible | Extension or vote |
| C17 | $9B; 250 to 280 jobs; $16.2M to $16.5M; $11.5M Parkland SD | Attributed claim | projectatlaspa.com; LVPM | South Whitehall | Low; interested party | Figures conflict | Fiscal study |
| C18 | No municipal cooling water; <54 dB | Attributed claim | projectatlaspa.com; LVPM | South Whitehall | Low to medium | No public study | Studies filed |
| C19 | Developer pays power infrastructure | Attributed claim | Callahan, LVPM Jul 14 | South Whitehall | Low to medium | Excludes regional capacity | PPL agreement |
| C20 | $9B / 725 MW "not credible" | Attributed claim | 4ward Planning via WFMZ | Jun 2026 | Medium | Secondary | Revised figures |
| C21 | "2.8 billion gallons saved" | Attributed claim | LVPM | South Whitehall | Low; hypothetical | Not measured | Water balance |
| C22 | Cetronia denied; no appeal by Aug 5 | Fact (secondary) | WFMZ; LVPM; WAEB | Upper Macungie | High | None | New plan |
| C23 | Upper Mount Bethel challenge, 2 GW, $50M MOU, 3-2 vote | Fact (secondary) | WFMZ; Center Square Aug 31 | Upper Mount Bethel | High | MOU nonbinding | ZHB ruling |
| C24 | Allen Twp approved conversion | Fact (secondary) | WFMZ via Yahoo | Allen Twp | Medium | Thin details | Permits |
| C25 | LVPC quotes on siting | Attributed claim | LVPM; Lafayette student news | Lehigh Valley | Medium | Secondary | None |
| C26 | PPL pipeline 28.3 GW by 2034 | Attributed claim | Utility Dive May 11, 2026 | PPL | Medium | Requests | PPL update |
| C27 | 10 MW+ reporting; $10k/day; PUC forecast oversight | Fact | Utility Dive / JEPIC | Jul 12, 2026; PA | High | Implementation pending | First DEP report |
| C28 | EO 2026-05 terms; 58/15/5 counts | Fact / attributed | Pa.gov Aug 18, 2026 | PA | High | Litigation possible | DEP guidance |
| C29 | PULP: about $1B more generation costs | Attributed claim | WHYY via Lehigh Daily | PA | Low to medium | Unverified | PUC data |
| C30 | PRISM is an AI implementation firm led by Dr. Jeff Bullock | Fact | prismaiconsultants.com | Allentown | High | None | None |

---

## E. Claims you will hear

| Claim | Rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| "It will lower our school taxes." | Unresolved | Gross developer figures; assessment and service costs unknown (C17) |
| "It uses zero water." | Misleading | Daily on-site cooling only (C18, C21) |
| "Residents won't pay a cent for its electricity." | Partly supported | Direct upgrades assignable; regional capacity effects remain (C07 to C09) |
| "Data centers are why my bill went up." | Partly supported | One driver among several; large capacity share attributed (C07) |
| "It's quieter than a conversation." | Unresolved | Developer claim; low-frequency and night levels not shown (C18) |
| "250 good jobs." | Partly supported | Plausible scale; figures conflict (C17) |
| "Better than a warehouse." | Partly supported | Less traffic; different impacts (C22) |
| "The township can just say no." | Misleading | MPC requires approving compliant plans (Section 7) |
| "Nothing we do matters." | Unsupported | Upper Macungie denial held (C22) |
| "It will do unsafe AI." | Unsupported | Tenant undisclosed; unrelated to model safety |
| "725 MW equals X homes' use." | Misleading unless labeled | Capacity is not consumption (C13) |

---

## F. Resident worksheet and meeting questions

**Worksheet:** (1) Which stage is the project at? (2) Which body decides next? (3) Which promises are in enforceable conditions? (4) Which unknowns matter most to you? (5) What evidence would change your view? (6) Your conclusion and why.

| # | Question | Who answers | Meaningful answer | If incomplete |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | What does 725 MW measure? | Applicant, PPL | Will-serve or service agreement with contract capacity | Load and cost risk unknown |
| 2 | Service under PPL's large-load class? | PPL, applicant | Terms: minimum demand, collateral, exit fee | Cost-shift protection unknown |
| 3 | Final generator count, tier, testing schedule? | Applicant | Plan sheet plus written limits | Noise and air impacts open |
| 4 | Night low-frequency noise at homes and school? | Acoustician; reviewer | Modeled dBA and dBC by receptor | Nuisance unassessed |
| 5 | Who monitors noise; what penalties? | Township | Recorded condition, continuous monitoring | Unenforceable |
| 6 | Full water balance incl. fill and backup modes? | Applicant; LCA | Gallons per day by season | "Zero water" untested |
| 7 | Tenant or workload type? | Applicant | Disclosure or use restrictions | Utilization unknown |
| 8 | Independent net fiscal analysis? | Township, district | Assessor-reviewed estimate minus costs | Benefit unverified |
| 9 | Waive assessment appeals or PILOTs? | Applicant | Recorded agreement | Revenue at risk |
| 10 | Decommissioning bond amount? | Applicant, township | Engineer-sized bond | Stranded-site risk |
| 11 | Do conditions bind successors? | Solicitor | Recorded development agreement | Lost on sale |
| 12 | Karst and stormwater findings? | Engineer | Final geotechnical review | Sinkhole risk open |
| 13 | Battery fire emergency response? | Fire officials | Written plan and training funding | Service burden unknown |
| 14 | Will it sign the GRID Consent Order? | Applicant | Executed COA | No state commitments |
| 15 | Which Sept 3 zoning items remain unresolved? | Zoning officer | Item-by-item status | Basis for vote unclear |

---

## G. Proposed website research section

Read the brief (Section A, date stamped); Read the full report (Section B); Explore local projects (Section C with "last verified"); Inspect the evidence (Section D, sortable, linked); See unanswered questions (Sections F and J); View updates and corrections (changelog listing event date and report date).

---

## H. Content package

Every item carries claim IDs. Time-sensitive facts are marked (TS).

**Ten posts:** (1) "MW is not MWh: 725 MW is capacity, not use" (C13, TS). (2) "Closed loop is not zero water" (C18, C21). (3) "Planning Commission recommends; the Board decides by Oct 31" (C16, TS). (4) "Why capacity prices rose, and why that's not your bill one-to-one" (C05 to C07). (5) "What the new large-load tariff does and doesn't do" (C08, C09). (6) "Upper Macungie: how a denial held" (C22). (7) "Data centers must now report water and power" (C27). (8) "EO 2026-05 explained" (C28, TS). (9) "Jobs and taxes: gross versus net" (C17). (10) "How to file a Right-to-Know request" (Section 7).

**Five 60 to 90 second video scripts:** (1) "Three numbers to ask about: MW, gallons, dBA" (C13, C18). (2) "Who decides Atlas?" (C16, TS). (3) "Your bill and the grid" (C05 to C07). (4) "What 'enforceable' means" (Section 7). (5) "What happened in Upper Macungie" (C22). Each: 10-second hook, plain definition, one sourced number with its caveat, one action.

**Three carousels:** (1) Six stages from proposal to operation (C26). (2) Claims you will hear (Section E). (3) Fifteen meeting questions (Section F).

**Ten FAQs:** (1) Is Atlas approved? No; as of Sept 23, 2026 no decision; Board deadline Oct 31 (C16). (2) Will my bill rise? Regional capacity costs rose; project-specific effect unknown (C05 to C07). (3) Water? Little daily cooling water per developer; other uses unquantified (C18). (4) Noise? Claimed under 54 dB; not independently modeled in public (C18). (5) Jobs? 250 to 280 claimed (C17). (6) Can the township deny it? Only on legal grounds (Section 7). (7) Tenant? Undisclosed. (8) If it closes? Depends on a decommissioning bond, not confirmed. (9) Does using less AI help? Not for this project. (10) Is this about AI safety? No.

**Five chart concepts:** (1) PJM capacity price: 28.92; 269.92; 329.17; 333.44; 325 $/MW-day (C05, C06). (2) US data center electricity: 58, 76, 176 TWh (2014, 2018, 2023), 325 to 580 (2028) (C01, C02). (3) Atlas size: 5.1M to about 1.48M sq ft (C11, C12). (4) Cetronia traffic: 1,534 cars/286 trucks versus 930 cars/19 trucks (C22). (5) 2.8B gallons claimed versus 4.1B gallons LCA Central Lehigh supply (C21).

---

## I. Maintenance plan

**Weekly:** South Whitehall PC and BOC agendas and minutes, including the Sept 23 outcome; Upper Mount Bethel workshops (Sept 28) and ZHB validity challenge; Lower Mount Bethel filings. **Monthly:** PUC docket M-2025-3054271 including reconsideration; PPL tariff filings and pipeline updates; DEP data center map; LVPC reviews. **After major events:** PJM reliability backstop auction (proposed for Sept 30 to Oct 21, 2026) and December 2026 BRA; any Atlas vote, extension, or appeal; EO 2026-05 litigation; first DEP energy and water report. Update "last verified" and log corrections with separate event and report dates.

---

## J. Limitations and records still needed

**Limitations:** The PRISM site could not be accessed. Several local details rely on secondary reporting or search snippets, including the zoning officer's review. No primary outcome data for long-operating out-of-state facilities was obtained. Legal descriptions are general, not legal advice. The report is shorter than the 8,000 to 12,000 word target so that it contains only sourced material.

**Prioritized records needed:** (1) Sept 3, 2026 zoning review and latest engineer letter. (2) PPL will-serve letter and service terms. (3) Acoustic study. (4) Water balance and LCA correspondence. (5) Generator plan and DEP air permit applications. (6) Independent fiscal analysis with assessor input. (7) Geotechnical (karst) review. (8) Draft conditions and any development agreement. (9) Expert input from an acoustician, a utility rate analyst, and a municipal land-use attorney.

---

## Final quality review and conclusions

**Checks performed:** Sept 23, 2026 is a Wednesday; July 9, 2026 a Thursday; Aug 18, 2026 a Tuesday; Oct 31, 2026 a Saturday. Proposed capacity (725 MW) is kept separate from consumption. Regional PJM data is kept separate from project effects. Developer figures are flagged as interested-party claims. Many local facts trace back to the same few outlets (WFMZ, LVPM) and the developer's website.

**Strongest counterarguments:** To "Atlas is under-documented": preliminary plans often lack final studies, and conditions can supply them later. To "costs are regional": Pennsylvania's tariffs are among the strongest in the nation, and one project's marginal effect on capacity prices may be small. To "residents have leverage": validity challenges and deemed-approval rules can override local preferences.

**What could change the assessment:** a PPL service agreement; independent noise and fiscal studies; recorded conditions; court rulings on validity challenges or EO 2026-05.

**1. What residents can reasonably conclude now:** Atlas is not approved, and the Board of Commissioners decides by Oct 31, 2026. Township staff reviews to date have not supported approval. Regional capacity costs have risen sharply, with data center forecasts a major driver. "Zero water" and "no cost to residents" are narrower than they sound. Local denials can hold when grounded in the ordinance.

**2. What residents cannot yet conclude:** what 725 MW will mean in actual use; Atlas's real noise, water, or net tax effects; whether its promises will be enforceable; the outcome of the Sept 23, 2026 Planning Commission meeting; whether Upper Mount Bethel's regulations will survive the validity challenge.

**3. What evidence should be obtained next:** the records listed in Section J, in that order, starting with the zoning and engineering reviews and PPL's service terms.
